Understanding MindBrain

 
 
Random Article


 
Latest Posts
 

The Mystery of Consciousness

 

 
Overview
 

 
Summary
 
 
 
 
 


 


Bottom Line

There is an interesting article in TIME, by Steven Pinker, about the study of consciousness. From the article: As every student in Philosophy 101 learns, nothing can force me to believe that anyone except me is conscious. This power to deny that other people have feelings is not just an academic exercise but an all-too-common […]

1
Posted January 21, 2007 by Bernard J. Baars

 
Full Article
 
 

There is an interesting article in TIME, by Steven Pinker, about the study of consciousness. From the article:

As every student in Philosophy 101 learns, nothing can force me to believe that anyone except me is conscious. This power to deny that other people have feelings is not just an academic exercise but an all-too-common vice, as we see in the long history of human cruelty. Yet once we realize that our own consciousness is a product of our brains and that other people have brains like ours, a denial of other people’s sentience becomes ludicrous. “Hath not a Jew eyes?” asked Shylock. Today the question is more pointed: Hath not a Jew–or an Arab, or an African, or a baby, or a dog–a cerebral cortex and a thalamus? The undeniable fact that we are all made of the same neural flesh makes it impossible to deny our common capacity to suffer.

And when you think about it, the doctrine of a life-to-come is not such an uplifting idea after all because it necessarily devalues life on earth. Just remember the most famous people in recent memory who acted in expectation of a reward in the hereafter: the conspirators who hijacked the airliners on 9/11.

Think, too, about why we sometimes remind ourselves that “life is short.” It is an impetus to extend a gesture of affection to a loved one, to bury the hatchet in a pointless dispute, to use time productively rather than squander it. I would argue that nothing gives life more purpose than the realization that every moment of consciousness is a precious and fragile gift.


Bernard J. Baars

 


One Comment


  1.  
    Aditya

    When discussing the Hard Problem, Pinker says:

    “… like the mathematician Roger Penrose, suggest the answer might someday be found in quantum mechanics. But to my ear, this amounts to the feeling that quantum mechanics sure is weird, and consciousness sure is weird, so maybe quantum mechanics can explain consciousness.”

    I wonder if Pinker doesn’t realize that Dr. Penrose’s Orch OR theory is based on more than blind conjecture, if he’s being disingenuous, or if he merely expressed himself poorly in that paragraph…





Leave a Response